it makes me pretty grumpy that people are happy enough to have corporations like google, amazon, facebook, et al know everything about them, but somehow a government ID is a bridge too far.
People can make the choice to engage with those companies, but the government want to force the matter. Plus of course I can always just stop interacting with the companies if I decide they have got gone too far. They won’t get any more data from me then. But I can’t opt out of governmental ID cards.
I don’t think it’s possible, in 2025, to opt out of engagement with these companies in any practical way.
The federal government already has an abundance of personal information about me. If they issue a digital ID I’m not providing them any additional information.
Whenever someone googles anything, they’re providing google with hew, intensely personal, information.
While you, personally, might take digital privacy seriously and leak less than a fishes asshole, we both know that the vast majority of people literally can’t take a shit without telling google how well their spouse’s new meds are working.
You can theoretically opt out of a great many things, but that doesn’t mean the behavior is practically possible.
People can make the choice to engage with those companies, but the government want to force the matter. Plus of course I can always just stop interacting with the companies if I decide they have got gone too far. They won’t get any more data from me then. But I can’t opt out of governmental ID cards.
I don’t think it’s possible, in 2025, to opt out of engagement with these companies in any practical way.
The federal government already has an abundance of personal information about me. If they issue a digital ID I’m not providing them any additional information.
Whenever someone googles anything, they’re providing google with hew, intensely personal, information.
While you, personally, might take digital privacy seriously and leak less than a fishes asshole, we both know that the vast majority of people literally can’t take a shit without telling google how well their spouse’s new meds are working.
You can theoretically opt out of a great many things, but that doesn’t mean the behavior is practically possible.